728 Cherry St Fort Collins, CO 80521

4 Bed
4 Bath
2,330 SqFt


$825,000
$354 /SqFt
For Sale
IRES MLS# 1064236

Single Family Home built in 1904 with a 5,954 SqFt lot in Subdivision: Longstein Sub

If you have always dreamed of living in Old Town do not miss your opportunity with this completely redesigned bungalow on Cherry St! Old Town charm meets modern comfort just steps from the Poudre River Trail and the heart of downtown. With two main level primary ensuites, this beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 4-bath bungalow offers the rare combination of historic character and thoughtful renovations in one of Fort Collins most sought-after neighborhoods. A welcoming front porch opens to a warm, light-filled interior where timeless architectural details blend seamlessly with modern design. The open living, dining, and kitchen spaces create an ideal setting for everyday living and effortless entertaining, featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and quality finishes. The spacious primary suite serves as a private retreat with vaulted ceilings, a walk-in closet, and a spa-inspired ensuite featuring a soaking tub, walk-in shower, and skylight. Second main-level ensuite provides flexible accommodations for guests, multigenerational living, or aging in place. The finished basement features 9-foot ceilings, full bath, kitchenette, recreation area, and fourth bedroom or office, offering exceptional flexibility for remote work, guests, fitness, or additional living space. Basement previously licensed as a short-term rental space offering income potential or a variety of future possibilities. Designed for today's lifestyle, the home includes availability of up to 10-gig Connexion fiber internet, dedicated office space, Nest smart thermostat, air sealing and insulation improvements, heat recovery ventilation, radon mitigation, and level two EV charger. Mature trees and thoughtfully designed outdoor spaces provide shade, privacy, and low-maintenance enjoyment. Walk or bike to your favorite Old Town spot from this unbeatable location! 728 Cherry Street offers a rare opportunity to experience the very best of Old Town living.


Visit Listing Website |

Virtual Tours:  1   2  



Request Info

General Features

Type Cottage/Bung, In-Law Area, Includes Rental Unit
Style 1 Story/Ranch
Baths 4 Full
Acreage 0.14 Acres
Lot Size 5,954 SqFt
Zoning OT-B
Total 2,330 SqFt ($354/SF)
Finished 2,330 SqFt ($354/SF)
Basement 90%+ Finished Basement, Built-In Radon
Garage 0 Space(s)
Garage Type None
Year Built 1904
New Construction No
Construction Wood/Frame, Composition Siding
Cooling Central Air, Ceiling Fan
Heating Forced Air, Zoned Heat, 2 or more Heat Sources, Humidifier, 2 or more H20 Heaters, Electric Air Filter
Roof Composition Roof

Taxes & Fees

Taxes $2,558
Tax Year 2025
Metro District No

Schools

School District Poudre
Elementary Putnam
Middle/Jr High Lincoln
Senior High Poudre

Rooms

Primary Bedroom 12 x 13 (Main Floor)
Bedroom 2 12 x 13 (Main Floor)
Bedroom 3 12 x 12 (Main Floor)
Bedroom 4 13 x 13 (Basement)
Kitchen 13 x 18 (Main Floor)
Living Room 15 x 14 (Main Floor)
Dining Room Main Floor
Laundry Room 7 x 11 (Main Floor)
Rec. Room Basement
Note: All room dimensions, including square footage data, are approximate and must be verified by the buyer.

Outdoor Features

Lawn Sprinkler System

Lot Features

Corner Lot, Level Lot

Design Features

Cathedral/Vaulted Ceilings, Open Floor Plan, Walk-in Closet, Skylights, Wood Floors, Two Primary Suites

Inclusions

Window Coverings, Gas Range/Oven, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Clothes Washer, Clothes Dryer, Microwave, Disposal, Smoke Alarm(s)

Neighborhood


Listing Agent

Molly Rothenbuehler

Molly Rothenbuehler

(970) 690-3285

IRES MLS
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed by the MLS. WARNING: This database record is provided subject to limited license rights. Duplication or reproduction is prohibited. Limited License MLS content and images © Copyright 1998 - 2026, IRES LLC. All rights reserved.